right_as_ellie wrote:I am not a Celine Dion fan not at all but she has an amazing voice and can sing pretty much anything.
Yeah the cover was one of the best i heard of RITD but still its lacking in terms of emotion to me has no soul .Yeah its almost perfect techically but for me thats not what RITD is about
I like Celine, there was a period (quite some years ago) when I used to listen to her constantly. But what you are saying reminds me a discussion I had with somebody on YT. Adele is sometimes called a "soul" singer, although some object it on the grounds that soul is a music reflecting black American's experience, and Adele does not fit this definition. However her vocal has this "soulish" tense, and intense, quality to it. I don't think anybody would ever try to call Celine Dion a "soul" singer. This kind of feeling is not there - for me. Still, for me there are 2 covers of Adele I heard that stuck in my mind as covers I liked, and this fragment is one of them.